James Politoski, 64, Tragically Killed in Laguna Beach Crash During Daughter’s Driving Lesson — Beloved Father and Community Member Mourned After Memorial Day Tragedy

Laguna Beach, CA — On Memorial Day, May 26, 2025, what was meant to be a meaningful rite of passage turned into a devastating tragedy as James Politoski, a 64-year-old resident of Laguna Beach, was fatally injured while supervising his teenage daughter’s driving practice. The crash occurred at approximately 2:43 p.m. in the upper parking lot of a shuttered Gelson’s Market at 24 Monarch Bay Plaza.

Authorities have confirmed that James Politoski, seated in the passenger seat of a classic Volkswagen Type-1 convertible, lost his life after the vehicle suddenly accelerated, broke through a safety fence, and plunged nearly 40 feet down an embankment. The car ultimately overturned and came to rest upside down on the Pacific Coast Highway between Wesley Drive and Montage Resort Drive, a typically scenic and serene stretch of coast that became the site of heartbreak on a holiday dedicated to remembrance.

A Day of Learning Turns Fatal

According to preliminary reports from the Laguna Beach Police Department, James was accompanying his 15-year-old daughter—who holds a valid learner’s permit—for a supervised driving session. The parking lot was presumed to be a safe, controlled environment for a novice driver to practice. However, investigators believe the teenager may have mistakenly hit the accelerator instead of the brake pedal, a common mishap among new drivers.

The sudden acceleration sent the vehicle barreling toward the lot’s perimeter. With little time to react, the car crashed through a retaining fence and nosedived down a steep slope onto the PCH. Despite immediate emergency response, James Politoski was pronounced dead at the scene. His daughter survived the crash with injuries and was transported to Mission Hospital in Mission Viejo, where she is recovering.

Laguna Beach Police Lt. Jesse Schmidt remarked during a press briefing, “Our preliminary investigation points to driver error—a likely confusion between the gas and brake pedals. It’s tragic under any circumstances, but especially devastating when it happens during a moment that’s supposed to be a shared, formative experience between parent and child.”

Who Was James Politoski?

James Politoski was much more than a name in a headline. He was a father, husband, neighbor, and mentor. Known in Laguna Beach for his warm demeanor, community involvement, and enduring love for classic cars, James was a fixture in the neighborhood. He could often be seen attending local car shows or helping organize community events at the local arts center.

Those who knew James describe him as kindhearted and generous with his time. “He had this calm, grounding presence,” said longtime neighbor Marlene Cortez. “Whether he was trimming the hedges or taking his convertible out for a weekend drive, he always waved, always stopped to ask how you were doing.”

He was retired from a long career in design consulting and had embraced post-retirement life with energy. He volunteered at local nonprofits and was particularly passionate about mentoring youth through afterschool programs. Friends say he had been looking forward to teaching his daughter how to drive for years, viewing it as a milestone in their relationship.

“He prepared for this like he did everything else—patiently and lovingly,” said close family friend Doug Winslow. “He wanted his daughter to learn to drive not just for the skill, but because he saw it as a moment they could share—an experience of trust, growth, and independence.”

The Scene and Emergency Response

The parking lot where the crash occurred was part of a now-vacant commercial property, formerly a Gelson’s supermarket, and had been frequently used by driving students and instructors due to its wide, empty layout. Despite being unofficially used for training, the lot is adjacent to a steep drop that is partially fenced.

After the crash, emergency personnel—including Laguna Beach Fire Department, local police, and paramedics—responded quickly to the scene. The Pacific Coast Highway was shut down in both directions for nearly three hours to allow rescue operations, investigations, and debris removal. Helicopter footage from local news outlets showed the overturned convertible on its roof, partially crumpled, with visible damage from both the fall and the impact.

Authorities have confirmed there were no other vehicles involved, and no pedestrians were harmed.

Investigation and Safety Measures

The Laguna Beach Police Department continues to investigate the circumstances surrounding the crash. No charges have been filed, and officials have indicated there is no suspicion of foul play, intoxication, or mechanical failure. Instead, the incident appears to be a tragic case of inexperience behind the wheel combined with a hazardous terrain.

Lt. Schmidt emphasized, “This wasn’t a case of negligence or recklessness. It was an accident—pure and simple. But it is a painful reminder that even controlled environments can pose risks, especially for new drivers.”

The crash has prompted discussions about improving safety around parking lots and disused commercial properties, especially those with high-risk perimeters. City officials are reportedly reviewing the fencing and terrain at Monarch Bay Plaza to determine whether additional barriers or warning signage should be installed.

Driving safety educators have also weighed in, noting that confusion between the accelerator and brake pedals is among the most common errors made by beginner drivers, particularly in high-stress or unfamiliar situations. “It’s not uncommon, but when it happens in a location with elevation changes, the outcome can be catastrophic,” said Richard Liu, a Southern California-based driving instructor.

A Community in Mourning

News of James Politoski’s death spread rapidly through Laguna Beach, a close-knit community known for its artistic roots and coastal charm. By Tuesday morning, a memorial had already begun to take shape near the crash site. Bouquets of flowers, handwritten notes, and even a miniature model of a classic VW Beetle were placed at the base of the slope where the accident occurred.

Summit Community Church, where James and his family had been members for over a decade, is organizing a candlelight vigil later this week. “James was a man of integrity, patience, and faith,” said Pastor Greg Tolland. “He believed deeply in teaching, in being present, and in creating moments of connection. It’s beyond heartbreaking that this moment, this simple act of fatherhood, ended in tragedy.”

A GoFundMe campaign launched by family friends to support medical expenses for James’ daughter and funeral arrangements has already raised tens of thousands of dollars in less than 24 hours.

Grieving While Supporting a Child

For the Politoski family, the grief is compounded by the emotional toll on a young girl who, at just 15, must process both physical recovery and the unimaginable burden of witnessing the loss of her father in a moment of shared experience. Trauma experts emphasize the importance of immediate psychological support and long-term counseling in such cases.

Dr. Elise Hernandez, a child trauma specialist, noted, “Survivor’s guilt, especially in familial contexts, can be deeply complex. It’s essential that the surviving child is not only reassured but surrounded by compassionate care. The community’s response and support can play a critical role in the healing journey.”

Looking Ahead

As investigations proceed and the Laguna Beach community continues to grieve, the story of James Politoski stands as a poignant reminder of how quickly life can change. A moment meant to teach independence and responsibility instead became a heartbreaking lesson in the fragility of life.

James Politoski’s legacy, however, extends far beyond the confines of that tragic afternoon. He will be remembered for the life he lived—one rooted in love, patience, and the quiet, unwavering support he gave to those around him. From classic car meetups to community service, from father-daughter bike rides to Sunday afternoons at Heisler Park, James’s memory lives on in every life he touched.

His death is not just a family’s loss—it is a community’s loss. And in the days and weeks to come, that community will gather to honor him not just as the man in the passenger seat on Memorial Day, but as the man who, in every way that mattered, showed others how to navigate life with compassion and care.

Related